Northwest Outdoor Report

New State Record Lake Trout Caught
Phil Colyar from Wenatchee just caught the new state record Mackinaw trout from Lake Chelan on Monday. The huge lake trout weighed 35 pounds, 10 ounces and beat the old state record by just 3 ounces. Colyar caught the fish in 270 feet of water in front of Kelly’s Resort on the south shore of Lake Chelan. After a 35 minute battle he and fishing buddy Jack Stagge raced to the nearby hospital in Chelan, which happened to have the only certified scale in the area. Colyar, Stagge, doctors, and nurses all watched as the scale ticked up to 35 pounds, 10 ounces. Colyar is having the fish mounted and plans to keep fishing for big Mackinaw’s in Lake Chelan, as he thinks there’s even larger Mackinaw to be caught in the lake.

American Lake Still Kicking Out Rainbows
Mike Barr from Bill’s Boathouse on American Lake says that anglers are still getting limits of nice trout fishing off the of the boathouse dock. He says a bunch of small trout in the 7 to 9 inch range just showed up, but the people that are putting in some time are going home with limits of trout in the 13 to 15 inch range. He recommends fishing yellow or lime green Power Eggs on the bottom in 12 to 35 feet of water. Barr says there’s definitely no shortage of trout in American Lake.

First Springer Caught on the Cowlitz
Todd Daniels from Tall Tails Guide Service knows of at least five spring Chinook being caught on the lower Cowlitz River this past week. Daniels says the springers have been caught in the Castlerock area and he knows that at least one of them hit a Kwikfish. There’s been sporadic reports of spring Chinook being caught on the Kalama River, as well. The forecast for both rivers is down this year with only 5,500 springer’s projected for the Cowlitz and just 700 spring Chinook projected for the Kalama River.

“Uncle Pete” Leading in the Roche Harbor Derby
After day one of the Roche Harbor Derby “Uncle” Pete Nelson is leading the derby board with a 16.7 pound blackmouth. Carter Whalen is in a very close second place with a 16.4 pound blackmouth and Derek Floyd and company are leading in the total weight category with 46 pounds 3 ounces. There’s still one more day to go in the two day derby and we’ll have more coverage and the final list of winners available on TheOutdoorLine.com.

Oly-Pen Salmon Derby Offers $22,000 in Cash
Tickets are on sale now for the Olympic Peninsula Salmon Derby happening February 16-18. The derby area extends from Freshwater Bay all the way to Port Ludlow and includes the banks in the Strait of Juan De Fuca and the western shore of Whidbey Island. Derby weigh stations are located at Freshwater Bay, Port Angeles, Sequim, Gardiner, and Port Townsend. Tickets are $40 apiece and derby chairman Dan Tatum expects well over 1,000 anglers to fish in the event, which boasts $22,000 in cash and prizes. John Otness from Tacoma won the event last year with a 17.60 pound blackmouth. The Outdoor Line will be fishing in the event and broadcasting live from Port Townsend next Saturday. For more information log onto GardinerSalmonDerby.org.

Hood Canal Derby Next Weekend
Tickets are on sale for the Bill Nik Memorial Derby next Saturday at Misery Point boat launch. The derby is ran by the Kitsap Poggie Club and boasts $2000 in cash and a ton of prizes. Last year’s derby was won by Shane Morrison with a 13.6 pound blackmouth he plucked from Hood Canal. Tickets are available at Kitsap Marina, Defiane Marine, Aqua Tech Marine, Brother Dons, Seabeck General Store, Papas Eats and Treats in Port Orchard, and Camp Union Saloon in Seabeck.

Maine Legislators Out to Ban Swim Baits
KeepAmericaFishing.org is reporting that legislators in Maine just introduced a bill that would prohibit the use of all “rubber” lures. The intent of the bill is to ban the soft plastic swim baits that most Maine anglers use every day. The bill would also ban the use of biodegradable swim baits, as well. Extensive tests have proven that plastic baits cause minimal problems for fish and they usually regurgitate them or pass them without problems.

REI Executive Named Secretary of the Interior
The Associated Press is reporting that President Obama just nominated REI’s Chief Executive Officer Sally Jewell as the new Interior Secretary. Jewell has helped push REI to nearly 2 billion in annual revenues and a place on Fortune Magazine’s “Best Places to Work”. The Interior Department manages more than 500 million acres in national parks and other public lands and more than 1 billion acres offshore. If confirmed by the Senate Jewell will replace current Interior Secretary Ken Salazar, who has announced he will step down in March.

Rob Endsley
The Outdoor Line
710 ESPN Seattle
www.theoutdoorline.com

Northwest Outdoor Report

Humptulips and Satsop Kicking out Coho
Patient anglers that waited until the end of the season to fill their freezers with coho were rewarded with great fishing this past week on the Humptulips and Satsop Rivers. Scott Sypher from Canyon Man’s Guide Service (206-518-4982) and Phil Stephens from Mystical Legends Guide Service (206-940-0052) both reported excellent silver fishing on both rivers. They both got quick limits on the Humptulips fishing eggs under a float two days ago and the fish have been big…running between 10 and 15 pounds. Over on the Satsop several fish in the 18 to 20 pound range have been reported the last couple of days, as well. These fish are often called the Christmas coho because the fishing usually remains good right up until Santa Claus rolls into town. The only problem is that the Northwest River Forecast Center is predicting that these rivers will be well out of fishable shape until as late as next weekend.

Cowlitz Slow for Steelhead
Outside of just a few winter steelhead being caught on the Cowlitz River fishing has been really slow there this past week. Derek Anderson from Screamin’ Reels Guide Service (206-849-2574) thinks the next high water should bring some fish into the system in the next week or so. The Northwest River Forecast Center is calling for the Cowlitz to ramp up to over 16,000 cfs by mid next week after a series of wet weather systems hits Western Washington, which is much too high to effectively fish for steelhead.

Blackmouth Still Holding off South Whidbey
When the weather allows for it Derek Floyd from Angler’s Choice Charters (425-239-5740) has been stroking the blackmouth at Possession Bar off the South end of Whidbey Island. Derek said he landed 13 legal blackmouth last Saturday on the bar and released another 5 wild fish before calling it a day. Floyd said it’s been tough to fish lately with all the wind, but when it lay’s he thinks the fishing will remain good. The Floyd fishing team will be heading to Friday Harbor the middle of this next week to compete with 70 other fishing teams and $15,000 in cash prizes in the Resurrection Salmon Derby.

Gillnet Removal on Tap for Columbia River
Sportsman may soon get their wish to have non-tribal gillnets removed entirely from the lower Columbia River. The Oregon and Washington Fish and Wildlife Commissions will meet at the Holiday Inn in Portland on December 7th and on January 11th and 12th in Olympia to vote on a plan to push gillnets off the mainstem of the lower Columbia and into designated off-channel netting areas. If the plan goes thru the sportfishing quota on runs like summer Chinook would be increase to 100% of the non-tribal catch. Sportsman would also see an increase in spring Chinook, fall Chinook, coho, and sockeye quota if the plan is approved. While the plan is very complicated many are hopeful that the gillnets will be removed and that a new era in sportfishing will dawn on the Columbia River.

Resurrection and Roche Harbor Derby Tickets on Sale
Tickets are still on sale for the Resurrection Blackmouth Derby in Friday Harbor next weekend. The Outdoor Line crew will be fishing in this derby and broadcasting live from the derby on Saturday. The derby is December 7th and 8th and boasts $15,000 in cash with $10,000 for 1st place. Log on to www.resurrectionderby.com for more information about this event. The next  big derby in the series is the Roche Harbor Derby held February 7th thru the 9th at Roche Harbor on San Juan Island. The Roche boasts $25,000 in guaranteed cash prizes and this year the resort will kick in an additional $30,000 for a winning blackmouth over 30 pounds. Tickets are $700 per boat for the Roche and registration forms can be found at www.rocheharbor.com.

Arizona Fish and Game Corrects False Press Release
Television, radio, newspaper and online news outlets carried a story this past week that elk hunters who hadn’t filled their bull elk tag at the end of the season would get a weeklong extension to their season. The Associated Press released the article without checking credentials and now Arizona Fish and Game officials are scurrying to clarify the situation. Officials aren’t quite sure where the press release came from, but suspect that an elk hunter with media access is behind the hoax.

Rob Endsley
The Outdoor Line
710 ESPN Seattle
www.theoutdoorline.com

One-Thousandth Group Joins Coalition as Leaders Focus Congressional Attention on New Economic Report

WASHINGTON – One-thousand groups and businesses have joined in urging Congress to consider the economic impacts of the great outdoors and historic preservation as it makes critical decisions concerning America's fiscal health, the recently formed national coalition "America's Voice for Conservation, Recreation and Preservation" announced today.

At a press conference held at the National Press Club in Washington, D.C., by the coalition on Monday afternoon, Theodore Roosevelt IV joined CEOs from prominent AVCRP organizations to cite strong new evidence of the employment opportunities and economic growth driven by natural resource conservation, outdoor recreation and historic preservation in America. Read a transcript of today's event and view video as it aired on C-Span 3.

Roosevelt, a leading figure in American conservation and the great-grandson of President Theodore Roosevelt, noted America's long-standing tradition of conservation. "For more than a century, conservation is part of what has made America unique," Roosevelt said. "From our public lands tradition to the ethic of private land stewardship, conservation has enjoyed broad support with the public and bipartisan support from their congressional representatives. As the Southwick Report clearly shows, conservation is an economic driver, accounting for more than 9.4 million jobs. I hope we reinvigorate our bipartisan commitment to conservation as we work to reduce the budget deficit."

Congress is currently determining federal funding of conservation, recreation and preservation programs in the bicameral, bipartisan "Super Committee" as well as in fiscal year 2012 appropriations bills.

AVCRP is a national coalition of organizations and businesses representing tens of millions of citizens with diverse political backgrounds and areas of interest. AVCRP members are united in a shared understanding that federal investments in natural resource conservation, outdoor recreation and historic preservation programs are vital to the future of our great nation. The 1,000 supporting entities signed a letter urging Congressional leaders to sustain the federal funds that are critical to the American way of life.

AVCRP represents an extraordinarily broad and diverse set of interests ranging from conservation and the environment to hunting, fishing and many other forms of outdoor recreation as well as historic preservation. AVCRP is made up of nonprofit organizations as well as major American businesses. Read the AVCRP letter and a list of signatories.

Other speakers at today's event included Dale Hall, CEO of Ducks Unlimited; Bill Meadows, president of The Wilderness Society and AVCRP co-chair; Stephanie Meeks, president of the National Trust for Historic Preservation; Mark Tercek, president and CEO of The Nature Conservancy; and Whit Fosburgh, president and CEO of the Theodore Roosevelt Conservation Partnership.

"The Economics Associated with Outdoor Recreation, Natural Resources Conservation and Historic Preservation in the United States," a report released this month by Southwick Associates and commissioned by the National Fish and Wildlife Foundation, was highlighted by Roosevelt and AVCRP leaders at the Washington, D.C., press conference. The study defines the huge economic stakes associated with continued federal investments that are leveraged and matched with private funds.

The study cites the following compelling figures for the combined value of outdoor recreation, natural resource conservation and historic preservation:
• 9.4 million American jobs
• $1.06 trillion in total economic impact
• $107 billion annually generated in tax revenue

"From an economic perspective, the bottom line is clear – America's natural resources are a critical part of our national economy. Investments in nature produce a great return. Federal spending on conservation and protection of our natural resources should not be singled out for disproportionate cuts in the budget," said Tercek. "Americans across the country agree, as you can see from support by more than 1,000 organizations joining together to call upon Congress to address the federal deficit while still investing in critical conservation programs."

"This economic report highlights how cost-effective conservation and preservation programs make a clear profit for the U.S. taxpayer and benefit our nation's economy," said Hall, who is also former director of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. "This coalition has come together because all of us understand how critical conservation, outdoor recreation and historic preservation are to America's legacy, economy and people."

"This study shows just how historic preservation has proven its value many times over," said Meeks. "The remarkable impact of the federal historic rehabilitation tax credit is just one example, creating over 2 million jobs since its inception and leveraging $90.4 billion in private investment. Preservation projects not only generate economic activity – it brings people together and creates a legacy for future generations."

Contact:
Vaughn Collins, 202-639-8727, vcollins@trcp.org
Alan Rowsome, 202-429-2643, alan_rowsome@tws.org

Northwest Outdoor Report for October 8th

Puget Sound Crabbing Re-opens Today
Seven marine areas of Puget Sound reopen for recreational crabbing today at 8 a.m.. Marine areas 4, 5, 6, 7, 8-1, 8-2, and a portion of area 9 north of a line between Olele Pt and Foulweather Bluff will be open to crabbing 7 days a week starting today thru December 31st. Marine areas 11 and 13 will reopen for crabbing on November 21st and Marine Areas 10, 12, and the southern portion of Area 9 will remain closed, as the catch quota’s have already been met in those areas.

Hunting Season Opens October 15
Deer hunters will take the field in most of Washington’s Game Management Units on October 15th and duck hunters will also get a 5 day season October 15-19, with a brief closure before main hunting season reopens on October 22nd. Pheasant season will open in Eastern Washington on October 22nd. For more detailed information about hunting seasons please log onto the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife website.

Showdown With a Grizzly Bear
Montana outfitter Erin Bolster and her horse “Tonk” will appear on the David Letterman Show on Tuesday night. The pair saved a young boys life from an enraged 750 pound grizzly bear  on a trail ride in the Flathead National Forest back on July 31st. Erin charged the bear three times with her horse before plucking the young boy to safety. You can catch Erin and her incredible story right here on the Outdoor Line after the next break.

House Bill Allows for Lethal Removal of Sea Lions
Tired of seeing sea lions feast on endangered salmon and steelhead at Bonneville Dam? House bill 3069 was passed on Wednesday that will allow for the lethal removal of trouble sea lions from the Columbia River and its tributaries.

The Endangered Salmon and Fisheries Predation Prevention Act allows Washington state, Oregon, Idaho and the four Columbia River treaty tribes to obtain one year permits from the Secretary of Commerce for the lethal removal of a limited number of sea lions from the Columbia river system.

Fishing License Sales Up in Washington
It’s not all gloom and doom for the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife these days. In the toughest economy in decades the department has managed to post strong gains in both resident and non-resident license sales from 2006 to 2010. The biggest jump in license sales came from 2008 to 2010, with sales increasing from just over 800,000 resident licenses sold in 2008 to nearly 1.1 million in 2010. A post has been started in the Outdoor Line forums if you’d like to chime in on this latest news.

NOAA Suspends Alaskan Catch Sharing Plan
NOAA’s decided to postpone the Alaskan halibut Catch Sharing Plan after receiving over 4,000 comments in opposition to it. The plan called for a reduction in the daily halibut limit in Area 3A, which includes the tourist-heavy Kenai Peninsula, to just one halibut per day. Halibut numbers have been declining in recent years in Alaskan waters and members of the North Pacific Fisheries Management Council have been scrambling to come up with a plan to stop the decline. Many point to the nearly 6.5 million pounds of bycatch from trawling in the Gulf of Alaska and another 2.5 million pounds of bycatch from the long line fleet. Commercial bycatch in Alaska is currently higher than the total recreational quota.

Rob Endsley
The Outdoor Line
710 ESPN Seattle
www.theoutdoorline.com

The Education of a Hunter

There's a scary statistic out there stating that if a youth doesn't experience hunting or fishing by the time they turn 18, there's a slim chance of him or her becoming an outdoor enthusiast in their lifetime.
So,  when my son Matthew turned 18, I knew it was well past time to get his Hunter Ed Certificate and get him on the trail to chasing his first deer.

One of the major obstacles to attending a traditional classroom Hunter Ed course just finding one close enough and fitting it in to a young man's busy schedule. Fortunately, WDFW saw the need for another option and now offers an on-line, home study hunter education program.  Today's kids are much more comfortable in front a computer screen than in a classroom and Matt tore right in to the on-line program.

 

Once the home study course was completed it was on to the Range Evaluation Session! The in-person skills evaluation is a required final step to receiving the all important Hunter Education Certificate which must be presented to purchase that hunting license and deer tag!

The class we found was at the Mount Vernon Trap Club in Skagit County. 

 

The instructors give a overview of the class and discuss what will be expected from the students during the firearm handling stage. 

 

The Range Evaluation consists of a series of common field situations such as crossing a fence, getting in and out of a boat, loading and unloading a variety of firearms and properly stowing firearms in a vehicle. 

 

After a successful run through the firearms "obstacle course" the students were treated to some live fire action on the trap range! 

 

Since our first father and son hunt will be an eastern Washington deer hunt, we needed to sight in the rifles and the Everett Sportsman's club Public range is a great, safe and affordable place to shoot.

 

One of the reasons the ESC's range is safe is that there are rules and the Rangemaster insists that everyone follows them! This is a well equipped range with targets for sale and bench-rests, sandbags and spotting scopes for your use! 

Matt even got a chance to shoot this Barrett semi-auto sniper rifle! A memorable day for sure!

 

We have a little more range work to do prior to hunting season but my trusty Ruger M77 .270 Win can still print a nice 100 yard group. 

There's still time to get your young hunter into the on-line hunter ed program. Log on and get crackin'!

Voting “fish” is only the first step

I received the latest issue of Sport Fishing Magazine yesterday in the mail and as I flipped through the pages I read an editorial that just blew my mind!

The article was by Doug Olander the editor and started off by telling of a group called National Resources Defense Council that wants people to boycott Shimano bicycle products.  The reason is because Shimano makes fishing products.

That's right, another attack on an American pastime that's been passed down for generations by some well funded, radical, uneducated environmental militia group.  These groups don't care about facts, science, or debate.  They have an agenda and it doesn't include people like you and me that enjoy fishing and feel enriched by creation after a day on the water.  We are literally on a battlefield right now and the recreational fisherman is under attack from all sides.

If you think that I am overreacting, then just take a look around.  Commercial fisherman are proposing an increase in the commercial harvest of striped bass in the NE and some in the commercial industry are trying to get longlining listed as a sustainable method of fishing.  Commercials are constantly pushing for more allocation and in Alaska they have successfully shut out new entrants to charters wanting to halibut fish.

Whacko environmental groups are using junk science to push for a lead band.  Marine spatial planning, MPA's and arbitrary fishing closures have become the norm.
Locally here in the NW we still have gillnets in our rivers, lakes, and saltwater.  We have a commissioner that proposed closing the state's most productive fishing grounds so that he can have a place to dive without being disturbed.

I could go on and on but hopefully you are hearing what I am saying, recreational fisherman need to stand up and be counted!  There are several ways of doing this but I believe these three are key.
It all starts with voting.  This is as American as apple pie and if you aren't going to make your voice heard at the ballot box then don't complain the next time a politician that doesn't know how to hold a rod casts a vote to deny you access. 

After we have the right people in office then it is accountability time.  Groups like CCA, NSIA, and PSA here locally and many other nationally are very active behind the scenes and need our membership.  For just a fraction of what we spend on ice every year we can pay dues or donate money. 

Lastly, we need to be actively involved.  Grass roots activism is something that I am afraid we are going to half to have going forward.  It's no longer just enough to vote or join, we have to be active on the front lines.  In reading Doug Olander's editorial I learned of a website managed by the American Sportfishing Association called, Keep America Fishing

The great thing about this website is that it is just asking you to act.

It doesn't require membership or money, although you can donate if you want.  Keep America Fishing  takes all the work out of it for you.  They let you know when new issues arise and tell you how to help with action items.  They have a Fishing Bill of Rights to sign, alerts, and news, both national and regional. Take a look at this site and I encourage you to sign up and then take action. 

It's time that we as recreational anglers become just as passionate off the water as we are on.
 

 

Leaning on the Wildlife Commission

The following letter, signed by ten Legislators of the State of Washington expressed what we sportfishers have known for a long, long time.

We are getting the short end of the stick and have been for years upon years… The difference now is that we have some political support to aid our cause:

 

The commercial crabbers response to this letter? They wrote a letter of their own to the Commission, an ultimatum really, threatening legal action if the Commission rules on the crab allocation issue on Friday, October 1, 2010. The Commission responded with a simple statement:

"The WDFW Wildlife Commission will be continuing on with the meeting agenda as planned". Bravo Commissioners! Bravo!!!

With pressure like this on the Commission, we need to support the "Stand-up Ten" Representatives who had the guts to stand up on behalf of the recreational fishermen of Washington State!

How do we support them? With our votes in less than six weeks during the November election.

 

The Economic Benefits of Conservation

Bryan Irwin, the PNW Executive Director of CCA, recently wrote this article for, The Ripple Effect, a CCA newsletter for PNW members.  This article is a real eye opener. With his permission I am able to share it with you.

When you examine the economics of recreational fishing, it’s clear that it fuels a major consumer goods and service industry. It also has a positive impact on conservation. How, you might ask? I have wrestled with that question over the years until I recently saw a statistic that was an eye opener when comparing recreational and commercial fisheries. 

Of our nation’s total fish harvest, 97% is commercial and 3% is recreational 1. Think about that for a moment. In the Pacific Northwest we spend countless hours arguing over a 5% swing in the allocation in the Columbia River salmon harvest, a number that is a rounding error in the total harvest of salmon when looking at the big harvest picture. 

Now, it stands to reason that we as a society are realizing a huge economic benefit from the commercial use of 97% of our marine resource, right?. Not really.  Nationwide, saltwater recreational fishing contributed $82.2 billion in sales to our nation’s economy and provides 553,000 jobs. Commercial fisheries (finfish) landings bring $28 billion in sales and 423,000 jobs 2. Yes you read that right, with 3% of the allocation the recreational sector contributes nearly 3 times to the US economy.  Closer to home in the Columbia Basin, recreational fisheries provide $35.8 Million in economic benefit compared to $2.1 Million from commercial (non-tribal and tribal combined) harvest.3 That’s 17 times more benefit from recreational fisheries with much less impact on the resource.

So, back to the conservation question. As harsh as it sounds, our harvested fish are essentially a resource, one in which our fisheries managers trade away the conservation benefits in exchange for the economic benefits. Sure, you could argue in isolated circumstances that some of this harvest is excess to conservation needs, but in most cases a harvested fish is one less fish to contribute to the next generation. If you look at the big picture, its pretty clear where we need to reduce harvest. The good news is that modest increases in the recreational share will more than offset any economic consequences of reducing the overall harvest.  And, reducing overall harvest benefits conservation.

Another conservation benefit of recreational fishing that provides economic value is the funding of conservation programs. I’m not talking about the support of CCA and other state and regional fish conservation groups; I’m referring to the unique tax on fishing tackle, motorboat fuel and other sportfishing equipment that has generated $5.7 billion for fisheries conservation, clean water programs and habitat restoration dating back to 1950. Our fishing license sales (nationally) give back $560 million annually to state conservation and education programs. In a very tangible way, the sportfishing economy gives back to the resource more than any other user group.There will always be room for commercial fisheries, as there should be. However, the current levels of harvest are not sustainable, and as our population grows, the pressure is just going to get worse.  But cutting sportfishing opportunities is not the solution. In fact, economics tells us the opposite is true.

Half the truth: agenda-based “journalism”

It appears that the Seattle Times is about to take its rightful place next to the National Enquirer on the tabloid rack in your neighborhood grocery store.

The article below appeared on the front page of the Times on Saturday, April 10, 2010. It featured a sensational headline sparsely embroidered in fact and the whole truth of the issue is not to be found anywhere within its text.

Nowhere in this unabashed attack on Sportfishing does it mention that the chinook in question are paid for by license fee increases agreed to by the salmon fishing public and the reader is led to believe that the entire Sportfishing industry is greedily feeding at the public trough contributing nothing to the greater state economy.

In fact, the "audit" that produced this "finding"  was originally called for by late Senator Bob Oake, a proponent of the blackmouth fishery who believed the funds generated by the license increase were being inappropriately used by the State for other purposes!
 
State on the hook for $768 for every salmon caught in Puget Sound
And audit revealed Puget Sound's popular blackmouth fishery costs $768 for every fish that's caught.

By Craig Welch
Seattle Times environment reporter

Puget Sound's popular blackmouth fishery — made possible by a complex system of hatcheries that produce and rear these plump young versions of chinook salmon — costs $768 for every fish that's caught.
That's a calculation made by the state Auditor's Office in an audit released Friday of the state's politically popular key winter fishery.
Each year the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife produces hundreds of thousands of the juvenile salmon in hatcheries, then raises them for 14 months or more in ponds until they lose the instinct to migrate. Then the fish are released for fishermen to hook for sport.
But some of the same environmental conditions that helped push wild chinook onto the Endangered Species list — such as pollution and habitat loss from development — mean few of the young blackmouth live long enough to get snagged. And the many fishing restrictions imposed in response to the 1999 listing of wild chinook also scaled back chances for anglers to try to catch the hatchery chinook.
That means catch rates for blackmouth are such a fraction of what they once were that the state may produce 900 fish for every one an angler nets. And each of those 900 fish costs about 85 cents.
"They're expensive to raise — more expensive than most fish," said Heather Bartlett, hatcheries division manager for Fish and Wildlife. "And their survival lately hasn't been very good."
The auditor's performance review suggested the program was so inefficient it must be changed, a charge Bartlett's agency doesn't dispute.
But the program's goals were dictated by legislative edict in 1993 as a means to sustain and promote sport fishing in Puget Sound. It's paid for by license fees derived from saltwater anglers, money that is dedicated to improving fishing. So as salmon listings have curtailed other angling opportunities, there's been little political will to cut back blackmouth production.
"Fishing used to be open unless we closed it," said Jo Wadsworth, Fish and Wildlife's deputy assistant director for fish. "Now it's closed unless we open it. And this is a unique fishery because it is open in winter when many other things are not."
Sport fishermen on Friday were immediately wary. The audit calls on the Legislature to change the law to let hatcheries produce far fewer and far younger fish — juvenile chinook that cost only about 11 cents each.
But that could reduce even further the number of fish available to be caught. And that frustrates longtime fishermen.
"Has this program always worked right? No," said Clint Muns, with Puget Sound Anglers. "But I think we've made great strides. The department's commitment to hatchery reform is without question." Environmentalists, meanwhile, say the recommendation would be a step in the right direction, but they believe the auditor missed the key issue. They say blackmouth production should have been halted years ago because the large hatchery-bred fish are built tough and compete with threatened chinook for food.
"The financial issues absolutely must be considered," said Kurt Beardslee, with Wild Fish Conservation Northwest. "But I always hoped they would kill this program for biological reasons — not just because we can't afford it."
Fish and Wildlife officials have said they support the auditor's recommendations.
Craig Welch: 206-464-2093 or cwelch@seattletimes.com


One of the comments on this article on the Times' website says it all:

"Wow, that is one impressive piece of analysis! The Seattle Times figured out that if you divide the cost of the program by the number of caught fish, you arrive at the cost per caught fish!

I wonder how much the performance audit cost that came up with this revelation? Say it cost $500,000, and they came up with 4 other similarly stupid findings. That would be $100K per stupid finding!"


This sad piece of misguided writing was bound to attract the attention of most, if not all in the Sportfishing community.

The legendary Frank Haw, acknowledged "Father" of the blackmouth fishery penned the following response:

All:
I was heavily involved in establishing the original program that began in the late 1960’s and continued to be successful well into the 1980’s (after I left the Department of Fisheries).  During the heyday of the program upwards of 10% of the “delayed releases” of Chinook salmon from south Puget Sound were subsequently caught by Puget Sound anglers.  Instead of migrating from the sound and residing off the west coast of Vancouver Island, the fish tended to remain in Puget Sound where they contributed heavily to a year-round fishery.  The resulting benefit/cost ratio was very high and the “delayed release” programs (for Chinook and coho salmon) were primarily responsible for establishing record sport catches in Puget Sound.

Since then conditions in the South Sound, including the primary holding area in a section of Olympia’s Capitol Lake, have worsened to the detriment of survivals.  Migration patterns have, on the other hand have apparently remained unchanged.  The mandating legislation was championed by State Senator Oake (deceased) during the late 1980’s as I recall.  As I understand, Senator Oake later called for the audit because he had reason to believe that the funds were being misused.  Since then questions have also arisen regarding the elevated level of PCBs in “resident” Chinook salmon.  


Instead of mandating the annual release of 3 million delayed release Chinook into Puget Sound (which, though never achieved is way too many) the program could better serve anglers by being more broadly goal oriented (e. g., increase the quality and opportunity for salmon angling in Puget Sound) and flexible to accommodate the changing productivity and fisheries management requirements.  As recommended by the audit, the HSRG should become involved in the program to some degree.   The inability to adequately monitor mark selective fisheries is a determent to harvesting fish that already exist and this could be use of funds that is highly beneficial to Puget Sound anglers.

As far as I know, the basic techniques used for producing resident fish are the same as we used 40 years ago.  The program should also focus new ideas, experimentation, and evaluation for the purpose of enhancing resident salmon populations.
Rather than defending the existing program we should be calling for the changes needed to make it successful.  This is obviously something of great interest to the Puget Sound Anglers and we should be working with them to establish a response.
 
Frank


Let this be a wake-up call to all who call Puget Sound "home" and enjoy treating family and friends to a day on the water. Get involved! Join CCA and Puget Sound Anglers!

The sad fact is that newspapers are going the way of the 8-track tape, the Drive-In theater and will evidently resort to sensationalism to survive. 

With drivel like this article by Craig Welch sullying the formerly proud tradition of the Seattle Times, I will find another use for this publication.

The Seattle Times will now be found hanging next to my water closet.

 

Tell Your Legislator to Back Off!!

Last year during the 2009 legislative session sportsmen and women stepped up to the plate and agreed to a two year 10% rate increase on their licenses to help cushion the blow from the massive $30 million dollar general fund reduction the state enacted for WDFW. To thanks us for our efforts and willingness to pay a price to enjoy our favorite family past time the state legislator is proposing further cuts of up to $10 million to the WDFW.  Enough is enough!!!

These additional cuts will lead to more layoffs in enforcement, closure of up to 5 more hatcheries that would directly affect the fisheries for salmon in Grays Harbor, on the coast, and in Puget Sound. In addition to these cuts, up to 60% of the budget for enhancement and salmon recovery could be cut. How can we continue to provide quality fisheries for our citizens, generate tourism dollars and grow the states tax base if we continue to cut from the WDFW? 

I for one am tired of paying a high price for these people to go to Olympia and be so fiscally irresponsible. They spend too much money when they have a surplus instead of doing what you and I do and putting a little away for a rainy day. Did they really think they were going to have a surplus forever? Why weren't they as responsible as you and I? Now Joe Fisherman has to pay the price once again. When will we get this $40 million in money from the general fund to flow back to WDFW? How much higher a price will you and I have to pay? Is that price getting so high that you will quit fishing and generating revenue for the state?  Will people continue to come to the State of Washington and spend money here to fish?

It seems to me the state would want to get as much of the billions of dollars that recreational fisherman spend each year to be spent here in the State of Washington. Wouldn't that generate some needed revenue? I here the "old timers" remarking that Washington used to be the salmon capital. Wouldn't the state coffers be better off if we could return to those days? If we keep cutting WDFW we will never get there. Recreational fishing could be a leading industry in Washington if the state would embrace it. Unfortunatley, they continue to look at you and I as little more than a side note.

 We need to make our voices heard, you can email your legislator and the governor.  I've already done it, join me in the fight.